Lightbuzzer
Member
- Joined
- Sep 24, 2025
- Messages
- 5
I keep seeing everyone slapping red dots on their carry pistols now, is this actually better or just the latest trend? I've been running irons forever and they work fine, but maybe I'm missing out
Red dots on carry guns
- Thread starter Lightbuzzer
- Start date
pasound
Member
They help when your eyes are getting old and that front sight is not as easy to find. I have them on my 22 target pistols, and on my Sig 365XL - a Romeo Zero.
30calflash
Member
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2025
- Messages
- 14
I'm a hold out on irons still, even being an old guy. I'm sure it has it's place but.....
3 years ago I attended a shooting event and met a friend there who had a Sig I think, with some kind of red dot. He had been home doing some repair work before getting to the range.
He handed me the pistol to check it out, I couldn't find the dot. Looked hard, wiggled it around for awhile but to no avail.
Gave it back and he started looking for it. After about 10 seconds plus he did, the reason it took awhile was he had been sanding drywall and the dust covered the lens (static) to where the dot was almost invisible. So, between my looking for it and his, we could have been in worse than a tight spot if it was needed at that moment.
So, I'll stick to my guns, with sights. I can see putting some hi visibility front sights on a couple that don't have them, or go tridium. But as far as a dot for carry, for my current purposes, no thank you.
3 years ago I attended a shooting event and met a friend there who had a Sig I think, with some kind of red dot. He had been home doing some repair work before getting to the range.
He handed me the pistol to check it out, I couldn't find the dot. Looked hard, wiggled it around for awhile but to no avail.
Gave it back and he started looking for it. After about 10 seconds plus he did, the reason it took awhile was he had been sanding drywall and the dust covered the lens (static) to where the dot was almost invisible. So, between my looking for it and his, we could have been in worse than a tight spot if it was needed at that moment.
So, I'll stick to my guns, with sights. I can see putting some hi visibility front sights on a couple that don't have them, or go tridium. But as far as a dot for carry, for my current purposes, no thank you.
I’ve been running a red dot on my carry gun for a while now and it does make target acquisition faster, especially when my eyes are tired and irons start looking like blurry chopsticks. The tradeoff is you’ve got batteries to worry about and you’ll spend some time hunting for that little dot until your draw stroke is dialed in. Once you get past that, it feels like cheating at the range...just remember, the optic won’t make you John Wick overnight… but it’ll get you a little closer
WV460HUNTER
Member
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2025
- Messages
- 17
On a SD carry redot is not needed most SD situations occurs in 7yards. At that range only thing needed is point and shoot off the front sight. In Hunting red dots are great for aging eyes.
30calflash
Member
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2025
- Messages
- 14
As some mentioned they have a place for those who need them in the field or for some match type events. I'm not sure on the SD end of things tho. My experience that one time underscored my feelings on them, for now. A bright and or night front sight is good for my aging lamps so far.
